The unfortunate end has finally come to my Youth Materials course, and what a fitting way to end it than with books about the end of the world…
The great thing about being an avid reader is that I can often disprove things to myself that I believe I like or dislike. For example, prior to the last two years- if I had heard the term ‘dystopia’, I would have equated it with a science fiction type theme. Where as that is not entirely off, many times dystopian tales involve elements of sci fi (like The Knife of Never Letting Go) the thing that was off for me was the fact that I liked these tales. I have never been much of a science fiction or fantasy reader, to me it gives the author too much license to just work the story the way that they want to and then credit anything that they can’t explain to ‘magic’. However, what I realized about good science fiction, is that the writer often has to be able to make up a bunch of things and explain them without copping out and crediting ‘magic’. This is why I loved our last picks for this semester, none of them copped out, instead these writers created startlingly real places and situations, they created worlds that I recognized but one that I also dreaded the coming of.
Here are my thoughts on these fantastic dystopian picks, spoiler note- I would recco each and everyone of them:
Little Brother by Cory Doctrow
This book is definitely a mind warper. Reading through it I was surprised at how the outrageous events all seemed to become commonplace and expected in the world that Cory Doctrow created. The book starts off with a group of friends skipping school to go play a video game type scavenger hunt. These teens seems pretty everyday except for the fact that they have to trick the school motion detector into not recognizing their walk and then avoid any cameras on the street for fear they will be turned into the truancy police. The main character and his friends live in a city that has a great degree of surveillance but that is accepted by the citizens because they believe that this will help the government protect them against any threats to their nation’s safety. In any case, Marcus (our main man) and his friends manage to escape and are just beginning their scavenger hunt when something goes horribly wrong. There is a ‘terrorist’ attack and the city’s bridge (san fran) crumbles and Marcus and his friends are captured by the Department of Homeland Security because their actions on that day were regarded as suspicious.
What follows next is truly terrifying and seems all too real. The teens are held for questioning and tortured when they won’t admit to any wrong doing. Eventually most of them are let go but not before allowing the government to hack into their phones and computers, and promising never to breathe a word to anyone about what happened. When Marcus gets home he realizes that one of his friends was not released and so he begins a campaign to overthrow governmental security and control over his city. Marcus becomes the leader of an underground movement of teens determined to take back their freedom. Whether he is tricking out X-boxes to create a new safe system or answering reporter’s questions through a SIMS like application- Marcus refuses to be outwitted by those who tried to take away his freedom and who still have his friend. Will he be able to save his friend or will the government capture him again and this time, perhaps he won’t come back.
This book is such a great read for those who like technology. Anyone who calls themselves a technophile will really devour this novel. The author does not skim over technology but instead offers up possible revampings. The author himself has a background of working with software and fighting for software rights, so it really lends an authenticity to the themes he is talking about. This book is a really relevant read in today’s Internet society where people don’t stop to question exactly what censorship entails. I think this would be a great book for today’s youth because it allows them to think and discuss after the book is read.
This book is also really authentically teenage- with the technology, the crushes, the rebellion- I think any teen who reads this will think it is a really cool read (though maybe they don’t say cool anymore, so I won’t mention that when recco’ing it).
The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness
Checking out ‘The Knife of Letting Go’, the first thing that I acknowledged was that on the back of the book, another author had praised that this book had the best first sentence. I was very curious to find out what this first sentence was. Slightly disappointed to find this:
“The first thing you find out when yer dog learns to talk is that dogs don’t got nothing much to say, about anything.” (it goes on to say “Need a Poo, Todd” and then “Shut-up, Manchee”.)
Maybe I am a bit old fashioned, but I just don’t think that is the most brilliant line ever, and also, I think starting a story with the fact that your dog needs a poo is not the classiest way to begin- but I held off on my judgement until I got through the book and luckily I did, because it turned out to be a really great story.
I will admit at times the story seemed a bit repetitive and simplistic, so perhaps this story would be better suited at pre-teens or younger teens.
The strength of this story was within the plot, Ness was able to create a world that was so fantastical and yet somewhat ground it in reality. If anyone ever told me that I would be able to believe that a world where no women lived in town, dogs talked and all the men could hear each other’s thoughts- I would have thought they were crazy but by the end of the novel I was completely sold on Ness’ story. There are also aliens, spaceships, and a love story within this novel. Again, I think this is a great recco because after reading it teens would have a lot to contemplate. I think I read somewhere that the author said he wrote this novel to talk about how in today’s society, we are constantly bombarded through things like social media, with other’s people’s thoughts and opinions. This novel is about what happens when all you’ve heard your whole life is the thoughts of other men, and now must begin listening to your own.
As well, the other great strength of the novel is in the creation of the hero, Todd. He begins the book as a reluctant hero but then slowly begins to realize its up to him not only to save the towns, but also to save the girl who dropped out of the sky into his life. This is a great novel for those who love an unlikely hero.
Unwind by Neal Shusterman
Unwind was the book that took the biggest leap of faith for me to believe n but it is also the one that still haunts my thoughts. Even the cover is spooky and conveys the desperation of the theme of the novel.
Unwind is about a society that makes people disposable, but not entirely. You see, parents have a choice- if by sixteen you are not considered a valuable member of society and they think that you may not live up to your promise, they can have you unwound. What that means is that you go to a space where your entire body is torn apart (but kept alive) and then catalogued based on your different parts. People who want your parts then can receive them. For instance, someone with a fault lung could wind up with your lungs after you were unwound. The book starts off with Conner, finding the papers his parents signed to have him unwound in the next few weeks. He deicides to escape, and on his way he ends up taking a hostage, a tithe. A tithe is a youth that is being unwound as a sacrifice to god. Len’s parents had 10 kids, and so a rule of their religion is they gave 1/10th of their success to god, and Len is the one child out of 10 they had chosen to sacrifice. Len has succumbed to his fate when Conner hijacks him to use him as a hostage. Along the way they also meet Risa, a soon-to-be unwound from an orphanage.
As the three struggle to remain incognito, the reader is treated to a changing in narration and each of the characters gets to tell their side of the story. This narration and characterization in this novel is very strong, and I could totally picture the characters in my head. The theme of a dispensable society was really quite interesting, and you could really feel the hurt/anger/sadness of all the unwounds as they tried to fight their fate.
This is a really strong story, I would give it to all teens even reluctant readers. The nice thing about this book is that the language isn’t too complex and the story switches views which can keep even the most bored reader’s attention. It was just a really hip read, I could see a lot of boys really liking this one.
Life as We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer
I honestly find it quite strange that I profess to liking ‘Life As We Knew It’ because to be honest, while reading it and even now reflecting on it, it is such a depressing read! Maybe that’s why I really liked it thought, the author does such a good job of conveying the despair of these characters and their situation.
Even as the book begins with the town looking forward to the moon being hit by a meteor. Even the passing nature f such an epic events reads true, or the fact that the people got out lawn chairs and sat around to catch a glimpse of the catastrophe. The way the author begins the story shows how tightly cocooned the town is in their comfy life. Miranda, the main character is in high school and is dealing with growing apart from her friends and family. When the meteor hits, all of a sudden everyone’s lives are turned upside down and they all have to fend for themselves as the world slowly starts to come to an end.
The book was so realistic. From filling up shopping carts of rations, to rationing the food they would eat, this book reminds me of a war diary. It is actually written as a diary from Miranda’s point of view. It shows how her, her mother and her two brothers cope with life and all the changes that come. She goes from attending high school to hardly ever leaving her house because she is too weak and the world out of doors has changed.
This book is a great read for teens who like stories about trying times, like the war. It is also a good read for those who like a bit of science fiction in their realistic fiction. I would highly recommend it even though It depressed me so much reading it. The funny thing is, today when I was googling for the cover- I discovered it was part of a trilogy and I couldn’t have been more excited!
How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff
This book was a bit slower for me to really get into. It actually reads quite simplistically, with short chapters and simple vocab. And actually the story itself has elements of a Narnia type or a Harry Potter- that element of orphaned children left to navigate the world by themselves.
The story begins with Daisy coming to England to live with her aunt and her cousins after her father’s new wife has exiled her there, saying it would be better for her pregnancy and for Daisy’s mental health to be away for awhile. When Daisy arrives she is struck by the uniqueness of her cousins. She describes each one of them in great detail as a sort of a fairy-tale character, you get the impression that these people are the types that are so magical, perhaps they can save Daisy from her depression.
Daisy’s aunt is involved in some sort of activism and she is off fighting for her cause when the war hits. She cannot get back into the country and as a result the children are left to fend for themselves.
Caught up in a war where nobody knows what has caused it, the only thing Daisy and her cousins can be sure of is that nothing will separate them. When something does, they have to work against the horrible odds to find each other once again- but how the war has changed them and will affect the rest of their lives is something none of them could have predicted.
I loved this novel for the sheer fact that despite it’s depressing backdrop- the war, depression, death of parents, etc. etc. etc.- it had this strange hopeful vibe to it, it was the mysterious magic to it all that kept the reader’s hopes up that all could not be lost. This book is written quite elementary but it seems to have darker undertones- I would recommend this to an older teen who likes an unconventional love story.
The Uglies by Scott Westerfeld
When I first cautiously started my foray into youth fiction- The Uglies was one of the first series that I devoured. It is my all-time favourite reco. Reading it again, I was surprised by exactly how badass it actually was- no wonder I had loved it so much and recommended it so often. It is easy to say that The Uglies has a great plot, and premise- Tally lives in a society where everyone gets turned pretty when they are sixteen and then goes off to lie a life of happy oblivion but her surgery is interrupted when her new friend runs away and the government tells Tally she can’t turn pretty unless she helps to find her. But it is more than just that, and that is what I forgot in between readings. Tally is such a wonderfully drawn out character, she is entirely believable and her struggles to decide between what is right and wrong and what she wants and thinks she wants is realistic. As well, the short chapters and language, really draw a reader in. I think this is a great book for readers who are starting out- it may seem a bit thick but the chapters are short and eventful, so you keep turning the pages.
I am going to have to go back now and read Pretties, and Specials (and I already started re-reading Extras since I own a copy). And I will also have to get the others in the ‘Life as We Knew It’ series and I heard Meg Rosoff has another haunting novel about a teenager named ‘H’- which intrigues me. I guess even though the term is done, I still have quite a bit of reading ahead of me! These dystopian novels leave me with an idea of a utopian break, reading my life away!